Friday, May 27, 2005

Lucky

Maybe Will Wilkinson needs to re-read his Thomas Nagel? Will discusses luck (not so much of a moral kind as of a metaphysical kind) here, in an interesting, albeit misleading, post about being Will.

Wilkinson, despite his best efforts, does get "thornily metaphysical" in his argument, and it is true that we can hardly disagree with him in his initial point. It is true that if something were different about a person, then they would not be that same person. For instance, if Will were a diabetic, he would not be Will, at least not in the same way he is Will now. A point not addressed in the post, but one that should be mentioned, is that time is an additional factor. Will is not a diabetic now, but he could develop diabetes (knock on wood) and still be Will; he would be Will at a different time.

It is true that his parents' actions were performed with the express purpose of creating in Will a certain work ethic or type of personality, and this is not luck. What IS luck, though, is the fact that Will's parents were cosmically matched up with Will. Here he reaches that thorny metaphysic; Will does not exist a priori, he only follows from his parents. If they were not his parents, he would not be Will. Will must be, of course, Will, and he could not be Will had he been born to different parents.

I'm not expressly disagreeing with Wilkinson, as the structure of definitions he's create has made it impossible to do so. What I can say, though, is that there is no real reason why I exist as a male, middle-class, while American while others exist as poor, oppressed, Indonesian women. Wilkinson's reason is that I could not exist as anything else, which is true, and yet I'm still disinclined to leave it at that, as anyone could be something else, had circumstances been different.

Thornily metaphysical, I know. Sorry.

9 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a no sugar added site/blog.

Come and check it out if you get time. :-)

2:27 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi
xanax cheap xanax buy xanax online phentermine buy phentermine online phentermine cheap tramadol buy tramadol online tramadol cheap levaquin buy levaquin online levaquin cheap lnorvasc buy sex online babe online casino online casino online
lroulette online blackjack online lpoker online phentermine online xanax xanax buy phentermine phentermine buy phentermine cheap
for fun

11:57 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi all!. Alone on Valentine's Day? Live adult chat Find sex partner in your area! Free offer
Enjoy

4:34 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi. Use this search engine for best result: TFOsearch Find all you need in your area!
Enjoy

11:51 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello
ATTENTION!!!
Only for adults!
Persons by whom it was not executed 18 years, the entrance is strictly prohibited!
It costs(stands) spent time, besides free-of-charge registration(To become a member) and numerous frank video(Only for members).
Welcome to Adult Porno & Sex.
Here pages devoted to health are published.
It is the large search robot, which can help to receive this or that information and as to get this or that goods!
Tramadol Xanax Phentermine Skelaxin Viagra and all that is necessary.
G'luck!

8:57 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's a real show............ Try to find sexy partner in your area !
- JOIN FREE - After free registration you can have unlimited access to the huge adult source.
ATTANTION ! Adult only !...... http://todaytop.tripod.com

6:07 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

For Greetings give sweets!
It's a little sex for health...
Welcome to sexy teens | movie pages | picture pages | webcam movie | adult friend finder.
Here pages devoted to health are published.
It is the large search robot, which can help to receive this or that information and as to get this or that goods! Tramadol | Xanax | Phentermine | Buy Xanax | Xanax and all that is necessary.
See you soon!

6:39 AM  
Anonymous viagra said...

The anti-impotency treatment you are going to adopt just after being identified with erectile dysfunction is not likely to yield any fruitful result if you do not abide by the precautionary instructions recommended by the physician. For instance, after procuring viagra online if you administer cheap viagra without providing the necessary details to the doctor with regard to your medical history then there are chances that viagra intake might prove disastrous to you. Most particularly, if you are taking nitrate based medicine such as nitroglycerin patches to treat a specific medical condition you should inform the doctor immediately so that he doesn’t suggest you to buy viagra. The usage of Viagra by any person using nitrate-based medicines can trigger off health disaster and as such you can definitely avoid the imminent harm by explaining your medical history to the doctor and avoiding to buy viagra online if the drug is not meant for you.

9:51 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Are you looking for you're at at a disadvantage over 18 years old and that you're receiving regular box office. [url=http://cleverpaydayloans.co.uk]uk pay day loans[/url] If you can afford proof of that you have a adducible bank a reckoning of and payday, you amperage have the acceptance to dally the accomplished fact and take it over to the next salaryday. There is no act of kindness of 18 years of age. Companies approach such loans will circumspectly appreciate your accounting for and once you meet the acid criteria, due to the active air of needs. Same day payday loans which are based problems that crop up between paydays that catch John Doe off-guard.

5:09 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home